Tuesday, September 23, 2025

Digital Voices and Legal Standing: Unpacking Murthy v. Missouri





Introduction:

Today social media is a big part of everyone's daily life. We especially saw the rise in use of social media during the COVID-19 pandemic. The use of these platforms has provided many citizens with the use of freedom of speech, especially when it comes to politics and current world news. In Murthy v. Missouri we see the question of standing in relation to the violation of the first amendment. To further understand how standing is used in cases, I will use the case mentioned as an example.

First let's review the meaning of standing. Standing refers to the right a litigant has to have a court rule upon the merits of a particular claim for which they seek judicial relief. In March 2024 social media users filed a lawsuit against the U.S. Surgeon General over censorship on social media platforms. During the COVID-19 pandemic platforms used their content moderation policies to suppress certain categories of speech, this was done to prevent the spread of misinformation. Federal agencies publicly and privately asked platforms to help prevent the sudden surge of misinformation. Similarly, these policies were used to prevent misinformation during the 2020 presidential election season. To better understand the key facts I will discuss below, here is the link where you can read the key findings on the case. 

Key Facts:
  • Plaintiffs claimed that multiple federal agencies engaged in censorship.
  • Censorship targeted conservative leaning speech.
  • Plaintiffs argued that defendants threatened regulatory action, like reforming Section 230 Communication Decency Act.
  • The suppressing of content violated their first amendment rights.
While reviewing the key facts we saw that the court concluded that the petitioners lacked standing and had two main reasons:
  1. The plaintiffs did not establish a causal link between their past social media restrictions and the actions of the government. Most plaintiffs could not show that their content was restricted because of government pressure rather than the social media platforms content moderation policies. 
  2. The plaintiffs could not demonstrate a substantial risk of future injury traceable to the actions of the defendants.
Considering the courts decision and what you know about standing what do you think?
  • Should the government be allowed to request the removal of content on social media platforms?
  • Do you think there could have been a way for the plaintiffs to link the social media restrictions to the government?
Citations:

Overview of Standing | Constitution Annotated | Congress.Gov | Library of Congress, constitution.congress.gov/browse/essay/artIII-S2-C1-6-1/ALDE_00012992/. Accessed 24 Sept. 2025.

“What Is Content Moderation?” Trust & Safety Professional Association, 19 Sept. 2022, www.tspa.org/curriculum/ts-fundamentals/content-moderation-and-operations/what-is-content-moderation/#:~:text=Most%20platforms%20began%20content%20moderation,their%20users%20and%20to%20proactively 

4 comments:

  1. Thank you for this post! I am going to focus my answer on the first question: Should the government be allowed to request the removal of content on social media platforms?

    In Professor Davies' class, we discussed the freedom of speech and what the current exceptions to free speech are: obscenity, fighting words/true threats, defamation, child pornography, and fraud. These exceptions uphold an important social concept: one person's right to free speech does not outweigh another person's rights to life, liberty, and the pursuit of happiness. This includes one's safety. Unfortunately, misinformation does not have its own distinct exception, and I think it would be extremely difficult to make a free speech exception for it. While I think arguments can be made for misinformation being fraudulent in nature, the gray area in the law that stems from a lack of an explicit restriction allows misinformation to seep through. Information on the Internet/social media spreads quickly and permeates algorithms that can connect users with endless content, leaving a pervasive but not easily traceable trail. Just as the plaintiffs struggled to tie their restrictions (or perceived restrictions) back to government action, it can be difficult to tie misinformation back to an original source. While I think it would be reasonable for the government to request the removal of misinformation and harmful content on social media platforms, I also think that this is an extremely difficult thing to regulate.

    However, misinformation can be combated with information literacy skills, and I believe it is more effective for the government and individuals/private organizations to promote information literacy. Libraries have been working alongside multiple other fields to combat the spread of misinformation. Libraries have a vested interest in teaching information literacy, and are educating people on the distinction between misinformation, disinformation, and malinformation (see this link: https://library.csi.cuny.edu/misinformation). The Venn Diagram on this site illustrates three different types of "information" that have harmful effects on a broader population.

    Concerns about the freedom of speech are ongoing, as we can see from recent events that have rocked Utah and the rest of the nation. It is not lost on me that President Trump and many others in MAGA leadership were setting themselves up to be proponents of the First Amendment and protecting free speech, but have abruptly changed their tune and now seek to silence Trump's political opponents and others who have been outspoken in their criticisms. Social media continues to be subject to abrupt and vicious shifts in social and political movements.

    I value the freedom of speech, but I also believe that it is the shared responsibility of the government and society at large to prevent the spread of false and/or malicious information. Similar to how we would hold a person accountable for causing a panic by falsely claiming that there is an immediate threat, there should be a greater responsibility placed on those (especially in positions of high influence and political power) to be vigilant in their stations and prevent the spread of malicious and false information, even if it is not yet effective or realistic for the government to request content be removed from social media pages. I am curious what others think: is it a government or individual/private responsibility to combat misinformation? Should false or malicious information become an exception to free speech on par with the other exceptions mentioned above?

    ReplyDelete
  2. Should the government be allowed to request the removal of content on social media platforms?
    No, but this is a complex issue. Tackling all issues related to social media is difficult since it functions very differently from traditional media in our society. This contrast became clear during the pandemic, when misinformation spread quickly online. The government was engaging with the platforms to address this issue, potentially paving the way for a more active government role in how it communicates with platforms about censorship. In the future, the government should avoid this practice to prevent being perceived as coercing these companies to censor speech.

    Do you think there could have been a way for the plaintiffs to link the social media restrictions to the government?
    I believe proving this might be difficult. Wouldn’t a traceable action need to demonstrate personal harm to the plaintiff? For example, if the government proposed removing a general type of post, would that not fail to show direct harm?

    ReplyDelete
  3. I don't believe the government should be able to request the removal of content on social media platforms. I understand the importance of managing how misinformation is spread, especially when the misinformation is centered on a global pandemic. However, when we think about the precedent it would set, I think we can see how it would be a slippery slope to allow the government to censor social media. I think Paulee hit the nail on the head when she mentioned the importance of information literacy skills. Because trying to regulate what information should be allowed on social media is almost impossible, media literacy is critical when reviewing anything posted on the internet. Paulee also mentioned the limits on our freedom of speech. We also learned in Professor Davies class that hate speech is protected under the First Amendment. I think misinformation would be similarly protected. Although misinformation can be harmful, I believe it would be really difficult to say misinformation as whole causes direct harm to public safety.

    ReplyDelete
  4. Should the government be allowed to request the removal of content on social media platforms?
    A: No, I can try to understand how the spreading of misinformation could be fuel for putting certain restrictions on social media posts and platforms, but what line is being created? Will the government say that their proposal is neutral for both parties, or is it likely that the government might allow more leniency for conservative voices/vice versa? I really did like Paulee's point about how there is a gray area that makes misinformation difficult to tie back to it's original publication, and misinformation is the core of this questionable idea. But what defines malicious? We'd have to set some core rules about what defines that, which is ultimately difficult because who's going to define that? The people or the government? Are we all going to agree on what defines malicious content, and is it likely that putting such enforcement will affect freedom of speech? If we didn't put regulations on posting false information, because essentially it is protected, we as a society have a role to distinguish between facts and fiction. The only question is: How?

    ReplyDelete

Note: Only a member of this blog may post a comment.

Swipe Left on Illegal Searches: Reimagining the Exclusionary Rule and the Fight for Digital Privacy

  The exclusionary rule holds that evidence obtained illegally cannot be used in court, making it a cornerstone of the Fourth Amendment . W...