Introduction:
On March 2025, Somerville Public Schools, located in Massachusetts, filed a lawsuit again President Trump challenging his executive actions to dismantle the U.S Department of Education. At the heart of this is a federal question, "Does the President have the constitutional authority to effectively shut down a cabinet level agency, created by Congress?" This case raises questions of separation of powers, the limits of executive authority, and the legal safeguards that protect federal education services. Before I raise discussion questions, let's dive into some questions and the key facts of the case.
Key Questions/Facts:
Q: What's the issue?
A: The Trump Administration issued an executive order to dismantle the U.S Department of Education. This included layoff of jobs, which ultimately cut half of the department's workforce and the end goal is to shut down the agency completely.
Q: Why?
A: Let's dive into the point of view of President Trump.
Benefits/goal of this issue:
-dismantling the DoE = shifts funding and authorities to state schools and district, which means less federal oversight
less federal oversight= reduce federal spending.
Q: What's the political message behind this? How would people support this?
A: "Our president is a president who challenges federal bureaucracy and returns powers to the people!"
Does this actually return power to the people? Partially. By reducing federal oversight, yes, states and local school districts have more control over funding and regulations. However, local school districts already have some control over their day-to-day operations. The Department provides funding, rights enforcement, and regulatory guidance. This just removes oversight and support.
Q: What are the allegations?
A: The President exceeded his authority because Congress has the power to create or get rid of a federal department. Plaintiffs are seeking a preliminary injunction to block these layoffs while the case proceeds.
Rulings and Jurisdiction Basis:
May 22nd, 2025, federal district judge granted the injunction, thus halting layoffs
July 14, 2025, U.S Supreme Court lifted the injunction allowing the administration to continue its plans while litigation is ongoing. This is a federal question jurisdiction because it challenges the constitutionality of the President's actions under federal law and the U.S Constitution.
So what do you think?
1.) Would dismantling the Department of Education truly "return the power to the people" or would it primarily reduce oversight and protections
2.) Could this case set precedent for future presidents to dissolve other federal departments?
3.) Do you think federal courts are the proper forum for resolving disputes like this or should it ultimately be left to Congress and the executive branch?
Footnotes:
federal question jurisdiction | Wex | US Law | LII / Legal Information Institute
Home | U.S. Department of Education
preliminary injunction | Wex | US Law | LII / Legal Information Institute

Dismantling the Department of Education would not literally "return the power to the people". Instead it would be shifting the federal responsibilities of funding, civil rights enforcement, and collection of data (national stats for accountability, practices/standards) from Congress to the states. The states already control K-12 education with limited authority over universities, so by giving them even more power could increase opportunities for misuse of authority and would widen existing disparities (of wealth, discrimination) between the states and communities.
ReplyDeleteI completely agree with you, Jessica, and I was interested to see that you included the collection of data as a responsibility being shifted from the federal government to the states. I saw multiple news reports today about the Nation's Report Card, and I thought that these reports further illustrated your point.
DeleteAccording to this NPR article I read (https://www.npr.org/2025/09/09/nx-s1-5526918/nations-report-card-scores-reading-math-science-education-cuts) about the Nation's Report Card, Trump's cuts to the U.S. Education Department included laying off more than half the workers at the Institute of Education Services (the organization specifically charged with measuring and interpreting National Assessment of Education Progress data). Moreover, the department needed to cancel about twelve assessments on both the federal AND state levels, many of which would have directly examined the educational progress of 12th graders. It is concerning to see that scores are dropping on a national level (with 12th grades reportedly dropping three points on their math and reading scores), and this is worsened by the fact that the tools to track and interpret these trends are effectively dismantled by Trump's cuts. It is further troubling to see that Trump's moves to "return power to the people" are frustrating Congress-mandated initiatives and directly disrupt states in their efforts to measure the effectiveness of their own educational programs. It is important to critique federal moves that seek to decentralize standards and protocols, especially when one branch of the government oversteps into the boundaries of another branch in the name of "states' rights." Continued educational instability caused by inconsistent government oversight will continue to deprive students of the strong foundation they require to build successful futures.
Thank you for your insight! To answer the questions posed in your post:
ReplyDelete1. The Trump administration’s push to dismantle the Department of Education was framed as a move to “return power to the people”, but this narrative severely oversimplifies the role of the DOE in ensuring educational equity across states. I think eliminating the DOE would not empower communities but it would expose students, especially in red states, to greater educational disparities. States like West Virginia, Mississippi, Louisiana, and Arkansas consistently rank among the least educated in the country and tend to rely more heavily on federal education funding than blues states. Without federal oversight and funding, these states would struggle to maintain even their current levels of educational support, disproportionately harming low-income communities.
2. Yes, I do believe that dismantling the Department of Education could set a dangerous precedent for future administrations. If a president successfully eliminates a major federal agency like the DOE, it opens the door to target other departments, such as Health and Human Services or the Environmental Protection Agency, based on political ideology rather than public need. This risks fracturing systems that were designed to ensure consistency, equity, and protection across state lines. In the case of education, removing federal oversight would leave students’ opportunities dependent on their zip code and deepen disparities.
3. I believe that federal courts are absolutely the proper forum for these disputes involving the Department of Education because they are responsible for interpreting federal law and ensuring executive actions comply with statutes like the Administrative Procedure Act (APA) . Given the DOE’s role in enforcing laws like Title VI and Section 504 and distributing federal funding, any attempt to eliminate it raises legal questions that only federal courts are equipped to address; therefore, judicial review is essential.
1. Framing the dismantling of the Department of Education as an attempt to “return power to the people” is especially troubling when you look at what the DOE actually does. For example, one of the important roles of the Department of Education is how it ensures civil rights protections for students who attend schools that receive funding from it. By dismantling it and removing that oversight, you could argue that administration is actually removing power from the people.
ReplyDelete2. I do believe it sets a dangerous precedent. If the administration can dismantle an agency under the guise of giving “the people the power,” I think it opens the door for them to impact more areas we once thought were protected. When the Supreme Court issued lifted the injunction and allowed the administration to continue dismantling the DOE while the case is working its way through the system, it opened up additional concerns surrounding the separation of powers. Justice Sotomayor expressed this concern in her dissent when she said, “…The majority is either willfully blind to the implications of its ruling or naive, but either way the threat to our Constitution's separation of powers is grave (Turner, 2025)." I also think it’s interesting that the decision was unsigned and offered no explanation, why do you think they didn’t explain their thinking when this case has such significant implications?
3. The issue being heard is rooted in the constitution, which would make federal courts the best forum for resolving the dispute. The judicial branch has the power to interpret and apply the law which is outlined in Article III of our Constitution. The Constitution does not give the executive or legislative branch branches this power.
Cory Turner, Supreme Court says Trump's efforts to close the Education Department can continue, NPR (Jul. 14, 2025, 5:02 PM), https://www.npr.org/2025/07/14/nx-s1-5443564/trump-supreme-court-education-department
Hi McKenna,
DeleteThat’s a really strong point. The Department of Education isn’t just about distributing funds—it also plays a crucial role in making sure schools uphold civil rights protections. Without that oversight, it’s not hard to imagine gaps in accountability, especially for vulnerable students. So while the idea of “returning power to the people” sounds appealing on the surface, dismantling the DOE might actually concentrate power in ways that leave many families with less recourse if their rights are violated. The lack of explanation is troubling, it basically leaves the public to guess about their legal reasoning. This might have been to move the case quicker, but what about transparency with the people? In other words, less reasoning=less ways to challenge their reasoning, possibly?
Dismantling the Department of Education would only reduce oversight and protections that it provides school districts. Like mentioned in your post, States already have some authority over the day to day operations of schools, so removing the DoE would not "return the power to the people" it would only create disparities among communities. Low-income communities would be stripped from resources and support as well as protections from discrimination. This can affect academic motivation and would likely lead to higher risks of students dropping out.
ReplyDeleteI believe that this could set a future precedent for Presidents that would want to dissolve federal programs in the future. After looking at the process of the case and especially noticing that the Supreme Court lifted the preliminary injunction, it is concerning to think that in the future this can be done while trying to dismantle other federal programs.
Education Week reports that states are already playing a crucial role in public education, including “providing up to 90% of funding for public schools.” They dismiss the argument that dismantling the Department of Education is about “returning power to the states.” The Department of Education is instrumental in enforcing federal statutes and protecting the civil rights of students (https://www.edweek.org/policy-politics/opinion-linda-mcmahons-fake-mission-the-states-already-control-education/2025/03). Eliminating the Department of Education would also result in the removal of programs designed to serve the most marginalized populations, as well as the oversight mechanisms that ensure individuals in need are able to access those services (https://www.nea.org/nea-today/all-news-articles/how-dismantling-department-education-would-harm-students).
ReplyDeleteDepending on the court's ruling, this case could set a major precedent for future cases involving presidential executive power. The judiciary plays a key role in maintaining the system of checks and balances, and its job is to settle constitutional disputes. As a result, the court should take on this case and make a decision.