Tuesday, October 7, 2025

Online Streaming Killed the Video Star: A Look at How Our Current Digital Landscape Demands More of Current Statutes

 



The timing could not be better, and I could not be more thrilled to be contacted about joining a class action settlement! Here are the details: 


  • The class action, Benjamin Garcia v. Brigham Young University d/b/a/ BYU Broadcasting, has reached settlement, pending Court approval. 

  • The plaintiff, who has a BYUtv account, claimed that Brigham Young University through BYUtv disclosed subscribers’ personally identifiable information (PII) to Meta via the Meta Pixel (a code that tracks visitor activity on a website) without consent. This action is alleged to be in violation of the Video Privacy Protection Act of 1988 (VPPA). 

  • According to the settlement page, BYUtv maintains that 1) the VPPA does not apply to BYUtv, 2) BYUtv did not share any PII with Meta, and 3) no privacy violations occurred. The U.S. District Court for the District of Utah, Central Division has not yet made a ruling on the case, and wrongdoing was neither found nor admitted. Both parties pursued settlement to “avoid costly and lengthy litigation.”

  • If the settlement is approved, BYUtv will be required to create a settlement fund as well as suspend operation of the Meta Pixel. However, BYUtv could resume using the Meta Pixel one of two ways: 1) The VPPA is “amended, repealed, or otherwise invalidated by judicial decision” to apply to current website activity tracking, or 2) BYU-tv “obtains VPPA-compliant consent” that would allow BYUtv to disclose details about content viewed by users to Meta. 


Our current digital landscape is ever expanding, and there are constant risks to everyday people’s data and personal information. However, many of our current laws have not yet been proofed for our digital age. Until laws are either amended or tested by legal arguments in court, many will remain inadequate to cover the rapidly-changing needs of our technological reality. 


Here are my questions for you: 

  1. How can laws written for a different technological landscape be applied to better meet the needs of the digital time we live in today? 

  2. Do you believe that the current wording of the VPPA is adequate to cover online audio visual content, or would future amendments be necessary to reasonably apply the law to online audio visual content? 


Citations

Meta Pixel Documentation - Meta for Developers. Available at: https://developers.facebook.com/docs/meta-pixel/ (Accessed: 07 October 2025). 

18 U.S. Code § 2710 - Wrongful disclosure of video tape rental or sale records, Legal Information Institute. Available at: https://www.law.cornell.edu/uscode/text/18/2710 (Accessed: 07 October 2025). 

Benjamin Garcia v. Brigham Young University D/b/a BYU Broadcasting - Home. Available at: https://www.garciavideoprivacyclassaction.com/ (Accessed: 07 October 2025).


5 comments:

  1. I'd like to think laws are - for the most part - written and passed with the intent of surviving not only present but any foreseeable issues that arise. That being said, despite tech having been around for years and years - it's only recently grown so quickly in both the type of tech and the use that has made it hard to anticipate what laws are applicable and necessary to pass. One way to address this dilemma would be to shift the effort of creating and amending laws to instead focusing on the foundational aspects of existing laws (like protection, privacy, accountability), relying on their original intent while then updating/adapting how those laws are applied and enforced to better suit the present issues.

    ReplyDelete
  2. Thank you for your insight and hopefully your class settlement ends well! I believe one of the most effective ways to strengthen alignment in today’s digital landscape is by ensuring legal professionals develop a deeper, working understanding of technology. This knowledge empowers lawyers, judges, and policymakers to craft legal frameworks that truly reflect the realities of our digital era. Additionally, this training can help legal professionals engage with emerging tools like artificial intelligence responsibly and keep ethics, transparency, and accountability at the forefront of their work.

    ReplyDelete
  3. Thank you for this interesting topic Paulee. Laws that have been written for a different technological landscape can play a valuable role in today's digital age by providing a foundational framework for addressing new challenges. While these existing laws may not have been designed for our current technologies in mind, they would offer guiding principles that may still be relevant to our technology today. Interpreting and adapting these laws can help create a legal framework that helps guide how we handle digital issues. However I do think that it is important that we don't rely on laws that may no longer apply to our digital era alone. As technology continues to evolve rapidly, these laws need to be updated and expanded to reflect the unique aspects of the digital age. Using the past as a starting point allows us to build more effective and future-ready policies that meet the needs of society in our increasingly connected world.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. I think it's so interesting how quickly technology is advancing our society, and although I can appreciate how beneficial it is, it definitely creates some gray area. If we do change our laws based on technology, I do wonder how much power technology has over our law-making, and if that's a good or bad thing. I touch on this in the paper I am writing in our other class and I appreciate the perspectives in this comment to aid with my piece!

      Delete
  4. 1. I think a major challenge for laws surrounding technology is how creative people can be when they break the law. Lawmakers can't always guess how someone may abuse technology, and our laws may be perpetually behind as new technologies are created. I liked how Erica mentioned that although current laws may not apply to changing technology, they can offer a guideline for new legislation. Kind of like how the protections in the fourth amendment have shifted and police need a warrant to search your cellphone. I don't think anyone was thinking of digital technology when they drafted the Bill of Rights, but using the fourth amendment and the laws created to help people maintain the rights within it has offered a framework for updating or creating new laws as technology changes.
    2. I think with the phrasing in section (a)(4) where it says "similar audio visual materials," allows for a broader definition that could include most digital material we see today. But with how rapidly technology has been changing lately, they may need to update some definitions in the near future.

    ReplyDelete

Note: Only a member of this blog may post a comment.

Swipe Left on Illegal Searches: Reimagining the Exclusionary Rule and the Fight for Digital Privacy

  The exclusionary rule holds that evidence obtained illegally cannot be used in court, making it a cornerstone of the Fourth Amendment . W...