Wednesday, October 22, 2025

AI and The Pro Se Litigant: The Impact of Technology on Litigation




Introduction: In February 2022, Allbaugh, a pro se litigant (and former attorney) sued the University of Scranton after not being selected for a position, alleging gender discrimination. Throughout court proceedings, an unexpected issue arose - the misuse of generative Artificial Intelligence (AI) in court filings. 


Key Facts: 

  • After Allbaugh filed the complaint, the University moved to dismiss for failure to state a claim. The Judge recommended granting the University of Scranton's motion under the Twombly-Iqbal standard while allowing Allbaugh leave to amend.

  • In his amended complaint and objections, Allbaugh included a potentially fictitious citation generated by AI prompting the Court to issue a show-cause.

  • Allbaugh responded by admitting to using AI and the Court found him in violation of several authorities: 

    • The Judge’s standing order regarding generative AI {1} (even though it was issued after Allbaugh's initial claim);

    • Rule 11 of the Federal Rules of Civil Procedure {2}, which requires parties to certify that their filings are not submitting false or fictitious material;

    • The Pennsylvania Rules of Professional Conduct {3}, which applies to attorneys.


Rulings: The Court OVERRULED Allbaugh's objections, GRANTED the University’s motion to dismiss, and SANCTIONED Allbaugh, ordering him to pay a $1,000 penalty for violating the Court’s standards


This case illustrates the growing dilemma between technological innovation and ethical responsibility within the justice system. While AI tools have the potential to make legal processes more accessible - especially for pro se litigants - they can also magnify risks when used without proper understanding, verification and disclosure. For individuals seeking justice without legal representation, AI can either be an empowering tools or a liability.


What do you think? 

  • Is there a way for courts to “ethically” embrace AI to support pro se litigants while preventing misuse?

  • What safeguards are necessary to maintain the integrity of the judicial process as technology continues to evolve?


Footnotes:

{1} Judge Mehalchick Standing Order Regarding Use of AI: https://www.pamd.uscourts.gov/content/judge-karoline-mehalchick

{2} Federal Rules of Civil Procedure (Rule 11): https://www.law.cornell.edu/rules/frcp/rule_11

{3} Pennsylvania Rules of Professional Conduct: https://www.padisciplinaryboard.org/for-attorneys/rules/rule/3/the-rules-of-professional-conduct


Tuesday, October 7, 2025

Online Streaming Killed the Video Star: A Look at How Our Current Digital Landscape Demands More of Current Statutes

 



The timing could not be better, and I could not be more thrilled to be contacted about joining a class action settlement! Here are the details: 


  • The class action, Benjamin Garcia v. Brigham Young University d/b/a/ BYU Broadcasting, has reached settlement, pending Court approval. 

  • The plaintiff, who has a BYUtv account, claimed that Brigham Young University through BYUtv disclosed subscribers’ personally identifiable information (PII) to Meta via the Meta Pixel (a code that tracks visitor activity on a website) without consent. This action is alleged to be in violation of the Video Privacy Protection Act of 1988 (VPPA). 

  • According to the settlement page, BYUtv maintains that 1) the VPPA does not apply to BYUtv, 2) BYUtv did not share any PII with Meta, and 3) no privacy violations occurred. The U.S. District Court for the District of Utah, Central Division has not yet made a ruling on the case, and wrongdoing was neither found nor admitted. Both parties pursued settlement to “avoid costly and lengthy litigation.”

  • If the settlement is approved, BYUtv will be required to create a settlement fund as well as suspend operation of the Meta Pixel. However, BYUtv could resume using the Meta Pixel one of two ways: 1) The VPPA is “amended, repealed, or otherwise invalidated by judicial decision” to apply to current website activity tracking, or 2) BYU-tv “obtains VPPA-compliant consent” that would allow BYUtv to disclose details about content viewed by users to Meta. 


Our current digital landscape is ever expanding, and there are constant risks to everyday people’s data and personal information. However, many of our current laws have not yet been proofed for our digital age. Until laws are either amended or tested by legal arguments in court, many will remain inadequate to cover the rapidly-changing needs of our technological reality. 


Here are my questions for you: 

  1. How can laws written for a different technological landscape be applied to better meet the needs of the digital time we live in today? 

  2. Do you believe that the current wording of the VPPA is adequate to cover online audio visual content, or would future amendments be necessary to reasonably apply the law to online audio visual content? 


Citations

Meta Pixel Documentation - Meta for Developers. Available at: https://developers.facebook.com/docs/meta-pixel/ (Accessed: 07 October 2025). 

18 U.S. Code § 2710 - Wrongful disclosure of video tape rental or sale records, Legal Information Institute. Available at: https://www.law.cornell.edu/uscode/text/18/2710 (Accessed: 07 October 2025). 

Benjamin Garcia v. Brigham Young University D/b/a BYU Broadcasting - Home. Available at: https://www.garciavideoprivacyclassaction.com/ (Accessed: 07 October 2025).


Tuesday, September 23, 2025

Digital Voices and Legal Standing: Unpacking Murthy v. Missouri





Introduction:

Today social media is a big part of everyone's daily life. We especially saw the rise in use of social media during the COVID-19 pandemic. The use of these platforms has provided many citizens with the use of freedom of speech, especially when it comes to politics and current world news. In Murthy v. Missouri we see the question of standing in relation to the violation of the first amendment. To further understand how standing is used in cases, I will use the case mentioned as an example.

First let's review the meaning of standing. Standing refers to the right a litigant has to have a court rule upon the merits of a particular claim for which they seek judicial relief. In March 2024 social media users filed a lawsuit against the U.S. Surgeon General over censorship on social media platforms. During the COVID-19 pandemic platforms used their content moderation policies to suppress certain categories of speech, this was done to prevent the spread of misinformation. Federal agencies publicly and privately asked platforms to help prevent the sudden surge of misinformation. Similarly, these policies were used to prevent misinformation during the 2020 presidential election season. To better understand the key facts I will discuss below, here is the link where you can read the key findings on the case. 

Key Facts:
  • Plaintiffs claimed that multiple federal agencies engaged in censorship.
  • Censorship targeted conservative leaning speech.
  • Plaintiffs argued that defendants threatened regulatory action, like reforming Section 230 Communication Decency Act.
  • The suppressing of content violated their first amendment rights.
While reviewing the key facts we saw that the court concluded that the petitioners lacked standing and had two main reasons:
  1. The plaintiffs did not establish a causal link between their past social media restrictions and the actions of the government. Most plaintiffs could not show that their content was restricted because of government pressure rather than the social media platforms content moderation policies. 
  2. The plaintiffs could not demonstrate a substantial risk of future injury traceable to the actions of the defendants.
Considering the courts decision and what you know about standing what do you think?
  • Should the government be allowed to request the removal of content on social media platforms?
  • Do you think there could have been a way for the plaintiffs to link the social media restrictions to the government?
Citations:

Overview of Standing | Constitution Annotated | Congress.Gov | Library of Congress, constitution.congress.gov/browse/essay/artIII-S2-C1-6-1/ALDE_00012992/. Accessed 24 Sept. 2025.

“What Is Content Moderation?” Trust & Safety Professional Association, 19 Sept. 2022, www.tspa.org/curriculum/ts-fundamentals/content-moderation-and-operations/what-is-content-moderation/#:~:text=Most%20platforms%20began%20content%20moderation,their%20users%20and%20to%20proactively 

Plea Deal or No Deal

 


It's no secret the the American criminal justice system is overloaded. Plea deals are one way to mitigate the congestion the court system has. A plea deal is a negotiation between the prosecutor and the defendant. Generally, prosecution will offer a lesser charge, or a dismissal of certain charges, in exchange for a guilty or no contest plea from the defendant. There are also other types of deals called pleas in abeyance that have similar use in the criminal justice system. Although plea deals can speed up the process and end cases sooner, there is controversy surrounding their use. We'll learn more about plea deals later on in the semester, but for now let's explore a few critiques that have been expressed.

One critique is the potential for coercion. When faced with the threat of harsher penalties or a prolonged stay in jail or prison, a defendant may agree to an unfair "deal," especially when the defendant represents themselves. Another criticism is the impact a plea has on justice. The "justice" argument is centered on the belief that in a plea, the outcome is based on the skill of the negotiators rather than the facts of the case, which can cause significant differences in the outcomes for similar cases (Plea bargaining in criminal defense: Pros and cons, 2024). I have seen this disparity myself many times as I've attended court across the state. I remember one court in particular where I heard two very similar cases in front of the same judge about one week apart. In one case, the defendant was sentenced to 24 months of probation while another defendant was sentenced to 7 years in prison. Again, the cases, even down to some of the facts, were very similar. I'd even argue that the case with the 24 month probation sentence was more egregious than the one with the 7 year sentence. Knowing the defense attorneys on each case, I absolutely believe it centered on their negotiation skills. 

The ACLU shares the concerns listed above. In 2020, Somil Trivedi from the ACLU Criminal Law Reform Project shared that plea bargaining "...lacks process, fairness, and often even rule of law (Trivedi, 2020)." In that same article, Trivedi goes over several cases where plea deals were less than fair. In one case, while a man was waiting trial on a separate charge, he was charged with assaulting a prison guard. The charge carried a mandatory minimum sentence of 10 years. Despite his knowledge that he didn't commit the assault, the man pleaded guilty due to the fear of spending 10 years behind bars. It took four years to find that there was video that proved his innocence, something prosecution would have had to share sooner if the case went to trial. This isn't the only time an innocent person has taken a plea deal that isn't beneficial to them, and it sadly won't be the last. 

Given the criticisms expressed above, I have two questions for the class:

1. Despite their obvious issues, are plea deals a necessary evil to prevent the criminal court system from becoming even more bloated?

2. Should there be more restrictions on when and how a prosecutor can negotiate a plea deal?

Citations

Plea bargaining in criminal defense: Pros and cons. The Abt Law Firm, LLC. (2024, October 23). https://www.abtlaw.com/blog/2024/may/plea-bargaining-in-criminal-defense-pros-and-con/

Trivedi, S. (2023, July 17). Coercive plea bargaining has poisoned the criminal justice system. it’s time to suck the venom out.: ACLU. American Civil Liberties Union. https://www.aclu.org/news/criminal-law-reform/coercive-plea-bargaining-has-poisoned-the-criminal-justice-system-its-time-to-suck-the-venom-out






Tuesday, September 9, 2025

Education on Trial: Fighting to Save the Department of Education





Introduction:

On March 2025, Somerville Public Schools, located in Massachusetts, filed a lawsuit again President Trump challenging his executive actions to dismantle the U.S Department of Education. At the heart of this is a federal question, "Does the President have the constitutional authority to effectively shut down a cabinet level agency, created by Congress?" This case raises questions of separation of powers, the limits of executive authority, and the legal safeguards that protect federal education services. Before I raise discussion questions, let's dive into some questions and the key facts of the case. 

Key Questions/Facts:

Q: What's the issue?

A: The Trump Administration issued an executive order to dismantle the U.S Department of Education. This included layoff of jobs, which ultimately cut half of the department's workforce and the end goal is to shut down the agency completely. 

Q: Why?

A: Let's dive into the point of view of President Trump. 

Benefits/goal of this issue:

-dismantling the DoE = shifts funding and authorities to state schools and district, which means less federal oversight

less federal oversight= reduce federal spending. 

Q: What's the political message behind this? How would people support this?

A: "Our president is a president who challenges federal bureaucracy and returns powers to the people!"

Does this actually return power to the people? Partially. By reducing federal oversight, yes, states and local school districts have more control over funding and regulations. However, local school districts already have some control over their day-to-day operations. The Department provides funding, rights enforcement, and regulatory guidance. This just removes oversight and support. 

Q: What are the allegations?

A: The President exceeded his authority because Congress has the power to create or get rid of a federal department. Plaintiffs are seeking a preliminary injunction to block these layoffs while the case proceeds. 

Rulings and Jurisdiction Basis: 

May 22nd, 2025, federal district judge granted the injunction, thus halting layoffs

July 14, 2025, U.S Supreme Court lifted the injunction allowing the administration to continue its plans while litigation is ongoing. This is a federal question jurisdiction because it challenges the constitutionality of the President's actions under federal law and the U.S Constitution. 

So what do you think?

1.) Would dismantling the Department of Education truly "return the power to the people" or would it primarily reduce oversight and protections

2.) Could this case set precedent for future presidents to dissolve other federal departments?

3.) Do you think federal courts are the proper forum for resolving disputes like this or should it ultimately be left to Congress and the executive branch? 

Footnotes:

federal question jurisdiction | Wex | US Law | LII / Legal Information Institute

Home | U.S. Department of Education

preliminary injunction | Wex | US Law | LII / Legal Information Institute

Friday, August 29, 2025

When Facts Matter: Ford Motor v. Montana and What it Means for Personal Jurisdiction (an illustrative post by a student in a prior year)

 



In today’s polarized society, it seems like there isn’t much that we can all agree on. However, the recent Supreme Court term proved that there was at least one thing all justices could agree on—at least when it comes to one specific set of facts in one specific case. The decision comes from a products liability case in Montana, and at its core is the issue of personal jurisdiction.

We will be learning more about the issue of jurisdiction in the coming weeks, but let’s just start with this: Personal Jurisdiction is the court’s power over the parties in a lawsuit. It is also a due process issue—is it fundamentally fair that a defendant in a lawsuit in one state can be compelled to travel to another state to defend themselves? Personal jurisdiction comes in two forms: general and specific. To illustrate the difference, let’s use the above-mentioned Ford Motor Company v. Montana 8th District Court case as an example. Here is a link that gives a brief summary of the facts and issues in the case. You should review this link before proceeding further. At the core of the case is a claim over a faulty 1996 Ford Explorer. 

Let’s take a look at the key facts:
  • Ford Motor Company’s principal place of business is Michigan.
  • The injured party was a resident of Montana, where the injury also occurred.
  • The car was not initially purchased in Montana, and plaintiff did not directly purchase the car from the Ford Motor Company.
  • The car was not manufactured in Montana.
  • Ford maintained a network of dealerships and service centers in Montana.
  • Ford advertised and marketed the exact model that caused the injury in the state of Montana at the time it was manufactured.
Given the above facts, the question before the Court was whether it was fundamentally fair for Ford to be required to defend itself in Montana (specific personal jurisdiction), or should the suit take place in Michigan where Ford is based (general personal jurisdiction)? Ford based its argument that the Montana court did not have personal jurisdiction over it on a decision in a 2016 Supreme Court Case: Bristol Meyers Squibb v. California, in which a similar case was dismissed because of a lack of ties between the plaintiffs and the state where the suit took place (California). However, the court found this to be a fundamentally different set of facts {1}. In the Montana case, the court found that Ford did have sufficient ties to Montana to justify bringing a suit there—through its networks of dealerships and advertisements—including advertising the very make and model causing the injury. This, alone, is enough to apply the principal of specific personal jurisdiction in this case {2}.

As you can see—facts matter! Change one or more of the bulleted points above, and the case could have been decided differently. Taking into account this brief summary I wanted to pose two questions:
  1. Of the above listed facts, which one would have the biggest impact on the outcome of the case if it were to change?
  2. Do you agree with the expanded view of what constitutes specific personal jurisdiction? Why or Why Not?

Footnotes:

Wednesday, August 13, 2025

Welcome to the Lawsuits & Litigation Class Blog

   This blog is an integral component of our Lawsuits and Litigation MLS course. The purpose of the blog is to (1) promote out of class discussion on topics related to the course and (2) raise litigation questions or legal issues that are of interest to you so they may be discussed in class. You will be making posts and comments on the blog throughout the semester. See the course syllabus for details.


The blog is private and is not visible to search engines, although if someone learned the Blog URL they could access it.  Only blog authors (myself and you all) may make posts or comments.  The blog uses the Blogger platform, which is a Google product. Consequently, you must have a Gmail account in order to post on the blog.

We are going to have a great semester!

Cheers,

Randy

Swipe Left on Illegal Searches: Reimagining the Exclusionary Rule and the Fight for Digital Privacy

  The exclusionary rule holds that evidence obtained illegally cannot be used in court, making it a cornerstone of the Fourth Amendment . W...