Tuesday, September 23, 2025

Plea Deal or No Deal

 


It's no secret the the American criminal justice system is overloaded. Plea deals are one way to mitigate the congestion the court system has. A plea deal is a negotiation between the prosecutor and the defendant. Generally, prosecution will offer a lesser charge, or a dismissal of certain charges, in exchange for a guilty or no contest plea from the defendant. There are also other types of deals called pleas in abeyance that have similar use in the criminal justice system. Although plea deals can speed up the process and end cases sooner, there is controversy surrounding their use. We'll learn more about plea deals later on in the semester, but for now let's explore a few critiques that have been expressed.

One critique is the potential for coercion. When faced with the threat of harsher penalties or a prolonged stay in jail or prison, a defendant may agree to an unfair "deal," especially when the defendant represents themselves. Another criticism is the impact a plea has on justice. The "justice" argument is centered on the belief that in a plea, the outcome is based on the skill of the negotiators rather than the facts of the case, which can cause significant differences in the outcomes for similar cases (Plea bargaining in criminal defense: Pros and cons, 2024). I have seen this disparity myself many times as I've attended court across the state. I remember one court in particular where I heard two very similar cases in front of the same judge about one week apart. In one case, the defendant was sentenced to 24 months of probation while another defendant was sentenced to 7 years in prison. Again, the cases, even down to some of the facts, were very similar. I'd even argue that the case with the 24 month probation sentence was more egregious than the one with the 7 year sentence. Knowing the defense attorneys on each case, I absolutely believe it centered on their negotiation skills. 

The ACLU shares the concerns listed above. In 2020, Somil Trivedi from the ACLU Criminal Law Reform Project shared that plea bargaining "...lacks process, fairness, and often even rule of law (Trivedi, 2020)." In that same article, Trivedi goes over several cases where plea deals were less than fair. In one case, while a man was waiting trial on a separate charge, he was charged with assaulting a prison guard. The charge carried a mandatory minimum sentence of 10 years. Despite his knowledge that he didn't commit the assault, the man pleaded guilty due to the fear of spending 10 years behind bars. It took four years to find that there was video that proved his innocence, something prosecution would have had to share sooner if the case went to trial. This isn't the only time an innocent person has taken a plea deal that isn't beneficial to them, and it sadly won't be the last. 

Given the criticisms expressed above, I have two questions for the class:

1. Despite their obvious issues, are plea deals a necessary evil to prevent the criminal court system from becoming even more bloated?

2. Should there be more restrictions on when and how a prosecutor can negotiate a plea deal?

Citations

Plea bargaining in criminal defense: Pros and cons. The Abt Law Firm, LLC. (2024, October 23). https://www.abtlaw.com/blog/2024/may/plea-bargaining-in-criminal-defense-pros-and-con/

Trivedi, S. (2023, July 17). Coercive plea bargaining has poisoned the criminal justice system. it’s time to suck the venom out.: ACLU. American Civil Liberties Union. https://www.aclu.org/news/criminal-law-reform/coercive-plea-bargaining-has-poisoned-the-criminal-justice-system-its-time-to-suck-the-venom-out






5 comments:

  1. Although my direct experience with plea deals has been limited to Justice Court cases—mainly infractions and Class C/B misdemeanors—I would say they have been essential in managing the number of cases that come before the court. And when they do come to court, plea deals presented to defendants give them a chance to weigh their options early on in the process, taking into consideration the available facts and the likelihood of different outcomes.
    That said, I believe the problem or "evil" aspect may not lie solely with the use of plea deals themselves but with the lack of accessibility—or unfair availability—of legal resources. Defendants may feel pressured into these plea deals without truly informed consent due to many different reasons (financial limitations, language barriers, or other challenges) which in itself is unfair. But as mentioned in the post - another unfair aspect is in the quality of a plea deal as it often depends heavily on the skill and experience of counsel. In this sense, while plea deals can be a practical necessity, I feel the underlying issue making them unfair is more so the broader inequality in access to legal knowledge/support.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. I agree with you that it’s not so much the plea deals as it is the systemic inequality within the justice system. Access to justice is frequently unequal, with wealthier individuals often able to afford better legal representation- they can hire experienced attorneys to post bail and secure quick releases, whereas poorer defendants often rely on overburdened public defenders and can spend months or even years in custody waiting for a resolution.

      Delete
  2. 1. I believe that plea deals are necessary within the current structure of the American criminal justice system because the system simply does not have the capacity to take every case to trial. Without plea bargaining, the backlog of cases would likely be unmanageable, thus delaying justice for victims and defendants alike.
    However, I would also agree that they are a “necessary evil”. The coercive nature of some plea deals, especially for marginalized or unrepresented defendants, is unjust and prioritizes convenience more than anything. I think the challenge is not whether plea deals should exist, but how they can be reformed to ensure fairness and transparency.

    2. To that point, I do believe there should be more structured guidelines and oversight around plea negotiations. Prosecutors hold significant power in the plea bargaining process, and without clear boundaries, that power can be misused. With reform, we could reduce the risk of innocent individuals pleading guilty out of fear, as in the case you mentioned.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Ooh, I actually really like the way you re-framed this idea. It shouldn't be about eliminating plea deals or not, but instead reforming them to ensure fairness and transparency. What about more judicial oversight of plea deals? This would require judges to review plea deals more carefully and review to defendants the consequences. Maybe we could also provide written record of negotiations. I think it's different for prosecutors to offer plea deals verbally, especially when it's shady or seems forced for the defendant, to hold accountability versus when's it written down as track record.

      Delete
    2. I like the idea you presented about more judicial oversight over plea deals. If judges were to review these deals more carefully and take into consideration the defendants criminal history, sentences would probably be different. Although I can see doing this could make court cases a lot longer and also create a bigger case load. I do think that maybe having a written record of these negotiations could help show how the negotiations are being made. I can also see how having a written record of negotiations could be used for future cases by other attorneys that are trying to make deals for their clients. I also think that there should be restrictions on when and how a prosecutor can negotiate a plea deal. Maybe having a closer window of negotiating a plea deal and a minimum set deal that wouldn’t allow a defendant to get away with a less than fair sentence. With my experience in court I have seen many cases where defendants get away with probation even though they have committed that same crime multiple times. I think that this doesn’t actually prevent recidivism as some defendants may feel that they can get away with receiving a lesser sentence.

      Delete

Note: Only a member of this blog may post a comment.

Swipe Left on Illegal Searches: Reimagining the Exclusionary Rule and the Fight for Digital Privacy

  The exclusionary rule holds that evidence obtained illegally cannot be used in court, making it a cornerstone of the Fourth Amendment . W...